Surly's Soap Box

That Woman is My Husband: A Study in Selfishness.
Last night, I caught a little of TLC's "My Unique Family".

"Jennifer and Chris have two loving children, successful careers and a beautiful home. Three years ago, Jennifer was a man named Jeff who decided to become a woman. Explore how this transition happened and the continued conflicts resulting from the change."


This wasn't a study of transition; it was a study of selfishness. You had this guy who was/is willing to abandon his wife and kids, bankrupting them in the process, to 'follow his heart' (thanks Oprah Windbag). The money he's spending, the damage he's causing his family, are all due to his trying to make himself feel better about himself, and everyone else be damned.

Tell you what, the human heart is not the guiding beacon our modern society has made it out to be. No, "The heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately wicked: who can know it? I the Lord search the heart, I try the reins, even to give every man according to his ways, and according to the fruit of his doings." Jeremiah 17:9,10



Posted by Surly Dave on Tuesday, February 6, 2007
Dan (mail):
I think you saw a different show than I did. The parents in that show were working very hard to keep the family together. And the father, despite gender transition, was working and bringing home the income necessary to support an obviously very expensive home, a horse for their daughter, etc.

Is Christianity for you just about judging others and feeling superior?
2.7.2007 12:52am
Uncle Ben (mail) (www):
Dan, it is certainly good to look at the positives, but how can you miss the obvious? He got a sex change operation! That isn't normal and it isn't good (even if he was single). The fact that he is putting his family through that makes it extra selfish. Criticizing Dave for calling him out on his selfishness when this man agreed to be on a nationally televised show is just silly. And must criticism come from feelings of superiority? Might it not come from genuine sorrow that people act in such destructive ways?

Quick question, can Christians legitimately make judgements on what other people do or not?
2.7.2007 4:40pm
Dan (mail):
The transitioning parent on the show did address the question of selfishness-- and I agree that it is a legitimate question to bring up. And of course we all make judgments. But jumping to judgment, without at least some empathy for others who are suffering (the transitioning parent, as well as the family), smacks of superiority, not genuine sorrow.
2.7.2007 7:28pm
Surly Dave (mail) (www):
Why is it that when ever a Christian makes an observation, it's immediatly condemned as judgement? Isn't that...being judgemental? Ah yes, Christians are to be seen but not heard. Of course, in our diverse culture, the only things not tolerated are people who point out bad choices and of course, Christians.


They maybe trying to keep the family together, but the wife was ready to acknoweldge that she had no idea if he was going to stick around. She saw no end to the surgeries, and he said he wondered what it would be like to be with men. At what point does he just jump off?

He is making selfish decisions totally based on self gratification. Period. He wants to make himself feel good about himself. His wife, who obviously loves him, has played along so far, but I think you could tell that she knows it's all going to collaspe. Why? Because at some point he's going to want something she can't give, and he will run away because she is stopping him from being the woman he was meant to be.

But my point was that the human heart is not the compass we should follow. The human heart is self serving, and only leads us to destruction. Why else is this guy mutilating his body?

2.7.2007 9:39pm
Robert Perry (mail) (www):
Is "Chris" the woman "Jennifer" had married? If so, I'm with Surly; the man promised her "till death do us part," and he's clearly (and yes, HE is still a HE despite his mutilation) decided to throw her rights down the toilet. Specifically, she has a right to exclusive sex with her husband, and also has a right expect that the resources God has given them will not be thrown down the toilet for the sake of his adulterous desires.

Moreover, any doctor who takes part in such mutilations should lose his right to practice, period.

One might object to being "judgmental" on the basis of Matthew 7:1. That said, continue through through Matthew 7:10; exactly how can one decide who the dogs and swine are apart from appraising the character of others?
2.8.2007 12:34pm

Post as: [Register] [Log In]

Account:
Password:
Remember info?